Hi Steps,If we looked at a 575 Workmate Hardtop,
Hull = 625
Outboard = 170
Fuel = 100
Crew = 400
Equipment = 100
Ballast = 200
Max total weight = 1595kg
Is a 115HP enough?
Thats
the max recommended HP for this hull. I do most of my cruising at
around the 22knot mark. I can't see any reason I'd need to do more than
30knots. Im more interested in maintaining speed in rough conditions
1st... having the power to maintain plain in seas has a unintended side effect... you get a faster cruise speed... and faster WoT.
1595 (1600kg) sounds on the rather heavy side to me
But lets go with that.
most boat around the size discussed in chop need to maintain around the 20/ 23 mph (19knt) not to fall off the plain
To travel at 19knt flat water requires around 55/60 hp generally around the 3300 rpms... then add another 10 to 15% reserve power on so you dont stall / slow on the wave in front..
thats 60/ 65 hp required.
Note here you are looking at around 22 knt cruise flat water... that not far off min plain.. that requires 60 hp...at around a cruise rpms of 3800/4000 rpms.
Drop a little speed and rpms in chop and you will be dropping on and off the plain.. having to put throttle in to get back up, go too fast , hit that next big wave and big bang..
See where this is going?
So lets go back to this
"General rule of thumb for a 5/ 5.5 6m boat a top speed at best trim flat
water around low to mid 40 mph fully loaded will achieve this.
Bare bones, 4 or 5 mph faster.
This will give a reasonable cruise speed on good flat ish water around the 30/32 mph in the 3800/ 4000 rpms range"
You have 1600kg which I think is on the high side ( quite a bit for a boat around 5.5m)
A fully loaded old commander .. spare prop, spar anchor, 3 guys ave 90 kg, fishing gear, full 110L tank, bimmini / clears, fishing gear etc is around the 1200/1250 kg)
115 hp at the prop was min hp.. hit a good chop and staying on the plain was a b1tch.. the big crashed down even more.
To get say 43mph (37knt) WoT you will need around 155 hp
If 115 hp is top spec to achieve the 37 knt the boat fully loaded will weigh about 1150/ 1200 kg... which I think would be far more in the correct range.. thu slightly on the light side.
Anything over 1200/1250 I would putting 115 hp as min and 140 max for best performance.
Now keep in mind the New 4S have a good 10 to 15% more hp than advertised...
So a modern 115hp 4S will have around 130 hp at the prop...
Also going on the few hp/rpm charts I do have.. will produce a little more than the required hp0 to maintain comfortable speed in chop without dropping off the plain
Basically the number back up what BH TB scampy all comment on the above.
And take note of the extra "200kg" ballast of the surtess.. and the extra hp to move the "1600kg" in chop and the repeated comments in other posts
Yesterday the Tamaki channel chopped up a little from the west.. so heading back up from Ponui was going to be a bit bumpy.. there was another boat about 1/4 of the way heading back, around a 5.5m alloy.. could not make out whatsort..
It was still well back from the ramp, having a crap job falling off the plain as we where pulling into the pontoon..
We 'cruied at 23 mph in the more heavy stuff, increased to 38mph as got into a little lea of land, and not a single thump.. The only thing that shork loose was the windscreen squeegee fall off the dash where there is no bar to hold stuff up at the end.
I must add thu we are around 10 hp over powered (150hp)
That is the difference of well powered and min powered.
PS falling off the plain chews a heap more gas... maintaining plain in chop, you use far less gas than even normal economic cruise...
If you take a min powered hull, (power requirement not boat specs) load a heap of ballast into the bottom, it will cut thru the waves better.. like the old heavy glass boats did..but you are damn near running a plaining hull as a displacement hull