Which hardtop?
Printed From: The Fishing Website
Category: General Forums
Forum Name: The Boat Shed
Forum Description: Discuss all things boating.
URL: https://www.fishing.net.nz/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=126786
Printed Date: 22 Nov 2026 at 9:27am
Topic: Which hardtop?
Posted By: offcut1
Subject: Which hardtop?
Date Posted: 08 Jan 2018 at 1:33pm
|
So, Im looking at upgrading to an alloy hardtop. Around the 5.7m mark. The main contenders at the moment are Senator RH580, Surtees 575, DNA 570 XHT and Frewza F18.
I was pretty set on a pontoon hull, mainly for the stability at rest and extra buoyancy if it all goes pear shaped. Obviously the downside is ride quality and extra weight. Thats why the Surtees is in the mix.
They all seem to be fairly similar in price, apart from the Frewza, which is a bit cheaper.
If Im honest, I like the look and finish of the Surtees the most. But, Ive never had anything to do with them. Is the flooding keel effective? I hate boats that slop around at anchor. Most of my boating is in fairly choppy conditions so ride quality is important.
Anyone out there who has experience with any of these boats and can give a comparison? Specifically, ride quality, build quality and stability at rest.
Cheers
|
Replies:
Posted By: paul_fishing
Date Posted: 08 Jan 2018 at 2:10pm
|
Hi Offcut, I suggest you to go for a ride all models in similar condition if you can. Surtees and Senator will give you different feelings due to different hulls.
I own a Senator RH580. It's been my pleasure so far. I took it everywhere in any condition. I smash the bar no matter how high the wave is. In a very choppy condition(talking 1.5m+ swell very short chop), you will never feel unsafe. You can still go relatively fast. Excellent stability at rest for pontoon. I have had 3-4 people on one side. It won't move too much. It is an excellent diving platform. The only thing I don't like is that you will get blown easily by wind. It is hard to do drift fishing cuz you will drift so fast.
Also, consider the space. My 580 has lots of fishing room at the back. We fish 4 comfortably that everyone can move around. The 5.7m boat market can be quite different for the fishing space at the back even though it is the same size boat.
Hope this help Cheers Paul
|
Posted By: Steps
Date Posted: 08 Jan 2018 at 2:59pm
l also suggest , check out the lay out.. what is best fort you. A 5.5/ 5.7m is not like say a 4.5 or even a 5m hull to walk around on... sure if 2 of 3 of your hang over one side, the boat will tilt over... And when under way, best to keep balanced to prevent bad 'wheel alignment' pull to one side. But bottom line in my books, in retrospect... get the layout/storage space top of the list.
|
Posted By: CanadianJohn
Date Posted: 08 Jan 2018 at 3:36pm
hey offcut,
i had the surtees 5.5 which is the same hull as the 575 from my understanding. mine had the smaller fuel tank which means bigger flooding keel capacity.
i have spent some time this year in a fyran 580 horizon hardtop. i wasn’t expecting much performance wise from it but i was wrong. i didn’t notice much difference at rest and underway to be honest. the fyran had a thicker heavier hull which probably helps it.
i loved the surtees and there is definately a difference at rest between when the keel is locked empty and flooded. and there is definately a difference underway between when the keel is locked flooded and allowed to drain. and in my opinion THIS is the one definate thing i can say sirtees have over other boats tue same length and general weight.
|
Posted By: yellafin
Date Posted: 08 Jan 2018 at 3:44pm
If you can try a Aqualine 565 Hardtop by Kiwikraft. It has a deep V and fine entry like the Surtees with the added benefit of pontoons. Goes very well in crappy conditions.
I think the DNA may be similar in specs. Don't know about the ride though.
|
Posted By: offcut1
Date Posted: 08 Jan 2018 at 5:47pm
Thanks for the replies guys. I see that Surtees also do a 5.5 hardtop now. Has anyone compared one to the 575? I’m in Christchurch and the dealer only has a 610 in the shop. I’m wondering how much deck space is lost by the 250mm drop.
The next question is what to put on the back. Probably looking at a 100 for the Surtees or a 115 for the pontoon boats. I’m looking for a boat for the next 20 years so long term reliability is more important to me than fuel efficiency. I’m between a Yamaha or a Mercury at the moment.
|
Posted By: CanadianJohn
Date Posted: 08 Jan 2018 at 6:10pm
|
i had a merc 90 2 stroke on the 5.5. wouldn't think thats enough for the hardtop but the difference between that and 100hp would not be big. i assume you're talking 4 stroke as well? (i think i'm one of the few 2 stroke fans left around) so you lose a bit of bottom end power apparently. go the 115.
|
Posted By: Schampy
Date Posted: 08 Jan 2018 at 8:34pm
Hi offcut. Surtees all the way mate. They do it all and yes the ballest tank makes a real difference. 575 Compared to the 610 its narrower in the beam, Cabin is the same size.... you can overnight... but you need to rest your head on a chilly bin unless you are a Hobbit.Obviously the 610 has it over the 575 in terms of ride and handling.... bigger, heavier boat is always gonna win. But theres not much in it -Considering the 25-30k price difference between the two... The 575 is great value for what you get. A 115hp 4 stroke will allow 30 mph cruising returning about 22 ltrs p/hr. Dont underpower the hull.... Surtees like plenty of hp.... especially if you fill the ballest tank... Go 115 if you can afford it. If I was to get another one (575) I would go for a 130.... screw the warrenty. I cant comment on thee Senator as a comparison...They seem very well built and no doubt have it over the Surtees when it comes to stability at rest. Like everyone says.... sea trial both. They both have there strong points. I could sit here all night and rave on about pros and cons etc..... But this was an interesting comparison.... A couple of weeks ago we took 2 boats out to Port Jackson and Channel Island from Narrow neck beach Devonport, my 575 and a mate had a Fyran 6.0 around mid 2000 vintage. After a great day of fishing, spearfishing and cray diving we headed home. The wind had picked up to around 15-18 knts from sw. We locked the water into the ballest tank and settled into a 25mph cruise all the way to scallop spot at the noises.... around an hour. In that time the Fyran had dropped back so far behind they were not even visible... They were getting punished....I actually thought they had broken down. Now....This is just an observation I made between the two boats... Im not bagging Fyrans....nor am I implying that a Surtees is vastly superior.... Just an interesting comparison made in real world conditions....and a 10 year differance between hull designs. Here in NZ we really are spoiled for choice....so many great boats.....
|
Posted By: offcut1
Date Posted: 08 Jan 2018 at 9:16pm
|
Hi Schampy,
Thanks for that. Interesting about the HP for a Surtees. I figured being lighter it could get away with a 100 but will price it on the 115 as well now. I like the pontoon boats for their stability at rest, but if the Surtees ride quality is a lot better in the chop that would sway me that way. The problem for me is getting a meaningful comparison. What we need is a demo day, where all manufacturers will give sea trials in the same conditions. The problem down south is that no one holds anything in stock. I might have to come up north for a couple of days and try to get on the water. Pretty good fuel numbers for you there. Im running a 75 merc on a 4.8m Zodiac and get about .9litre/mile so it sounds like Ill be saving on gas.
|
Posted By: shaneg
Date Posted: 08 Jan 2018 at 9:47pm
Only my opinion .... but have spent time on 5.5 meter surtees (been to White Island 2 days in a row in one and fished a fair bit around gulf in one), It had a Honda four stroke 90hp on and seemed adequately powered. The surtees are capable craft. However a good pontoon boat, one that has a decent vee on it and is not too wide will deliver better sea keeping both at rest and underway in "all" sea conditions overall. Good pontoon boats are less prone to broach or bury nose particularly in large following seas, easier to quarter a head sea, slightly harder riding into a head sea with chop. For size pontoon boats are generally heavier by design hence not requiring flood chambers, the only real drawback is compromising beam internally and useable space in cabin and cockpit. And some say they are ugly. My ride is a 17 yr old 490 stabi.. In most seas excepting completely flat sea it outperforms a surtees even the much bigger 5.5 mtr one but it lacks internal room ... basically a two person boat, some have said a very big Jetski
|
Posted By: Steps
Date Posted: 09 Jan 2018 at 9:35am
How well a hull performs , espec when in chop etc depends on how much reserve power there is to punch thru the next wave without slowing or falling off the plain... fully loaded There fore is is very important to power well, which means .. like your wifes shopping basket car, will have a top speed way beyond what you will use or need...Fully loaded General rule of thumb for a 5/ 5.5 6m boat a top speed at best trim flat water around low to mid 40 mph fully loaded will achieve this. Bare bones, 4 or 5 mph faster. This will give a reasonable cruise speed on good flat ish water around the 30/32 mph in the 3800/ 4000 rpms range The required power can be calculated for most boats as the hull designs for trailer boats are limited by the beam thu it must be noted the surtees does require more power due to hull design to achieve the same expectations
There is little difference these days (modern alloy boats now have thicker hulls ) between most glass and alloy boat weights. Go at least the max spec hp engine .. get a little over powered say another 10 hp also makes a huge difference to hull performance in seas, and cruise speed.. and if travel at the same or just above the old cruise speed, pick up a good 10% better economy.
Comparing boats can only be done by correctly propping the boat for its end purpose (be it general use, skiing, towing, racing etc) Then re power with different engine and then repropping correctly for the same purpose.. It is no good comparing power/ boats between hulls , espec when drop the deeper surtees into the mix.
Also its a good idea when sea trialling, load the boat up as if it was fully loaded ....and note also the chances are it will be propped for the light load performance (as in most marketing reviews) .. so the extra load will also make a difference espec if min powered..
Bottom line thu... Sort out" 1/ what you intend to use it for most of the time 2/ what your expectations are for cruise speed flat ish water fully loaded at a given rpms. 3/ calc the required hp to move that total weight at that speed rpms, then add another 10 to 15% for reserve power
|
Posted By: offcut1
Date Posted: 09 Jan 2018 at 9:54am
|
Hi Steps,
If we looked at a 575 Workmate Hardtop,
Hull = 625 Outboard = 170 Fuel = 100 Crew = 400 Equipment = 100 Ballast = 200 Max total weight = 1595kg
Is a 115HP enough? Thats the max recommended HP for this hull. I do most of my cruising at around the 22knot mark. I can't see any reason I'd need to do more than 30knots. Im more interested in maintaining speed in rough conditions. Ie, fully loaded on a rough day I'd want to be able to get up on the plane quickly and hold somewhere around 16-18knots.
|
Posted By: Bounty Hunter
Date Posted: 09 Jan 2018 at 12:26pm
offcut1 wrote:
Hi Steps,
If we looked at a 575 Workmate Hardtop,
Hull = 625 Outboard = 170 Fuel = 100 Crew = 400 Equipment = 100 Ballast = 200 Max total weight = 1595kg
Is a 115HP enough? Thats the max recommended HP for this hull. I do most of my cruising at around the 22knot mark. I can't see any reason I'd need to do more than 30knots. Im more interested in maintaining speed in rough conditions. Ie, fully loaded on a rough day I'd want to be able to get up on the plane quickly and hold somewhere around 16-18knots.
|
this discussion has been worked over multiple times in the past. the general consensus that results is that 90/100hp is okay but doesnt offer sparkling performance.
the surtees hulls dont offer a lot of lift with their 'minimal' chine flats and as a result tend to be a bit hp hungry.
if you want more 'go' - opt for the max hull rating - which is 115hp - and was referencing the old yamaha 115hp 4stroke. yamaha now have the new 130hp which is the same motor as the 90 and 115 - and i would expect that surtees would have no issue with this newer, higher output engine going on the transom.
you also mentioned that slow planing speed was desirable - installing trim tabs will help a lot with this, and will help you offset the surtees trait of lying on the windward chine when travelling across the weather.
------------- No disintegrations!
|
Posted By: Bounty Hunter
Date Posted: 09 Jan 2018 at 12:29pm
|
and going back to the 'stability of the pontoon' hulls - remember that sealed chambers only offer buoyancy - not stability.
stability comes from hull form and vertical center of gravity.
------------- No disintegrations!
|
Posted By: JustAnotherSpearo
Date Posted: 09 Jan 2018 at 7:42pm
offcut1 wrote:
Hi Steps, I do most of my cruising at around the 22knot mark. I can't see any reason I'd need to do more than 30knots. |
Mate.. you say that, but from experience if it costs next to nothing to go a little quicker on nice days you end up doing it.. The next outboard on the 520 lazer at this stage (whenever the lil 90 dies) will be the lightest 115 / whatever the max HP same weight as the 115hp.
The size you are looking at id be wanting to go up a fair amount. Steps does make sense with the economical cruise aspect. 90hp on the 520 when fully loaded with spearos (3 adults) achieves 31mph on the flat days trimmed up at 5000rpm. an extra 120kg from one guy + gear makes a huge difference for us, our WOT goes from 40mph down to 38mph
|
Posted By: Schampy
Date Posted: 09 Jan 2018 at 8:19pm
|
Like I said,if I were to get another 575 I would opt for the 130 Yam. Its a longer, heavier boat than the 5.5 ( 5mm hull = 90 kg extra weight) The throttle works in both directions. Like Bounty said.... stacks has been written about Surtees love of HP on the stern. Nothing changes in 2018...Dont over-think it. Just go for max you can afford and be happy with it. cheers Lance.
|
Posted By: 3rnzir
Date Posted: 09 Jan 2018 at 10:27pm
Do you really need a hard top? Reason I ask is Can you get a high glass option in the seated position? And use clears instead. Hardtops do provide excellent cover,but do tend to act like a sail at sea. Clears on the other hand,when removed,negate this sail effect to a significate degreee. Though clears should really be called opaques. Hence quality glass to be installed at seated height. The fold down option for garaging is also an prospect with clears if space/is an issue . Hard tops gernerally add 15% to the new purchase price. Welding finishing/painting etc.
------------- Peace.Via superior firepower..
|
Posted By: Time_Bandit
Date Posted: 10 Jan 2018 at 8:26am
Where are you getting your info that a yammy 90 115 130 are the same ???
------------- “Be yourself; everyone else is already taken.”
|
Posted By: Grasshoppa
Date Posted: 10 Jan 2018 at 8:57am
Time_Bandit wrote:
Where are you getting your info that a yammy 90 115 130 are the same ??? |
Pretty widely known fact that all these models share the same 1832cc power plant, checking any online brochure/website will confirm Theres also less than 10kg weight difference across the range Would suggest the stated horsepower differences are due to different states of engine tune via ECU
|
Posted By: Steps
Date Posted: 10 Jan 2018 at 9:41am
|
Hi Steps, If we looked at a 575 Workmate Hardtop, Hull = 625 Outboard = 170 Fuel = 100 Crew = 400 Equipment = 100 Ballast = 200 Max total weight = 1595kg
Is a 115HP enough? Thats
the max recommended HP for this hull. I do most of my cruising at
around the 22knot mark. I can't see any reason I'd need to do more than
30knots. Im more interested in maintaining speed in rough conditions
1st... having the power to maintain plain in seas has a unintended side effect... you get a faster cruise speed... and faster WoT.
1595 (1600kg) sounds on the rather heavy side to me But lets go with that. most boat around the size discussed in chop need to maintain around the 20/ 23 mph (19knt) not to fall off the plain To travel at 19knt flat water requires around 55/60 hp generally around the 3300 rpms... then add another 10 to 15% reserve power on so you dont stall / slow on the wave in front.. thats 60/ 65 hp required. Note here you are looking at around 22 knt cruise flat water... that not far off min plain.. that requires 60 hp...at around a cruise rpms of 3800/4000 rpms. Drop a little speed and rpms in chop and you will be dropping on and off the plain.. having to put throttle in to get back up, go too fast , hit that next big wave and big bang.. See where this is going?
So lets go back to this "General rule of thumb for a 5/ 5.5 6m boat a top speed at best trim flat
water around low to mid 40 mph fully loaded will achieve this. Bare bones, 4 or 5 mph faster. This will give a reasonable cruise speed on good flat ish water around the 30/32 mph in the 3800/ 4000 rpms range"
You have 1600kg which I think is on the high side ( quite a bit for a boat around 5.5m) A fully loaded old commander .. spare prop, spar anchor, 3 guys ave 90 kg, fishing gear, full 110L tank, bimmini / clears, fishing gear etc is around the 1200/1250 kg) 115 hp at the prop was min hp.. hit a good chop and staying on the plain was a b1tch.. the big crashed down even more.
To get say 43mph (37knt) WoT you will need around 155 hp If 115 hp is top spec to achieve the 37 knt the boat fully loaded will weigh about 1150/ 1200 kg... which I think would be far more in the correct range.. thu slightly on the light side.
Anything over 1200/1250 I would putting 115 hp as min and 140 max for best performance. Now keep in mind the New 4S have a good 10 to 15% more hp than advertised... So a modern 115hp 4S will have around 130 hp at the prop...
Also going on the few hp/rpm charts I do have.. will produce a little more than the required hp0 to maintain comfortable speed in chop without dropping off the plain
Basically the number back up what BH TB scampy all comment on the above. And take note of the extra "200kg" ballast of the surtess.. and the extra hp to move the "1600kg" in chop and the repeated comments in other posts
Yesterday the Tamaki channel chopped up a little from the west.. so heading back up from Ponui was going to be a bit bumpy.. there was another boat about 1/4 of the way heading back, around a 5.5m alloy.. could not make out whatsort.. It was still well back from the ramp, having a crap job falling off the plain as we where pulling into the pontoon.. We 'cruied at 23 mph in the more heavy stuff, increased to 38mph as got into a little lea of land, and not a single thump.. The only thing that shork loose was the windscreen squeegee fall off the dash where there is no bar to hold stuff up at the end. I must add thu we are around 10 hp over powered (150hp) That is the difference of well powered and min powered.
PS falling off the plain chews a heap more gas... maintaining plain in chop, you use far less gas than even normal economic cruise...
If you take a min powered hull, (power requirement not boat specs) load a heap of ballast into the bottom, it will cut thru the waves better.. like the old heavy glass boats did..but you are damn near running a plaining hull as a displacement hull
|
Posted By: offcut1
Date Posted: 10 Jan 2018 at 10:55am
|
Thanks for the input guys. Steps, the 1600kg is an extreme number. Obviously fully loaded you don't have to carry the keel ballast so max of 1400kg is probably more reasonable. It looks like the 115 would be the way to go for a 575.
Does anyone know much about the 550 Workmate Hardtop? Is it a big step down from the 575 in terms of ride and deck space? 25cm doesn't seem like much but it depends where it is lost from.
The one boat off my list I haven't had a look at yet is the Frewza F18 hardtop. Considering the Frewza fan forum on here is 160 pages long I thought I'd be overcome by Frewza owners. Anyone had much to do with them? They look like a hard riding boat to me but they seem to have a lot of fans.
|
Posted By: Steps
Date Posted: 10 Jan 2018 at 4:37pm
It looks like the 115 would be the way to go for a 575. Personally for many modern models of boats in a very competitive market, far too often the max hp rating falls a little short of ideally powered ... Getting up around the 1400/ 1500kg I would certainly be looking more at the 140/ even 150 hp at the prop.
... some of the manufactures will supply a new tag at a extra cost for insurance purposes...
Alloy boats are noisy espec smaller ones under 6m+meters.. wave slap etc, cold in winter
|
Posted By: Kandrew
Date Posted: 10 Jan 2018 at 6:05pm
|
Where does the 115 maximum hp for the 575 come from, my mates got a 150 Yamaha on his and it needs every bit of it in a big sea
|
Posted By: sarge
Date Posted: 10 Jan 2018 at 7:28pm
|
i have had limited time in the F18, just one trial and not enough to judge or form opinion. As far as i could tell the workmanship was good and it was in the consideration for a new boat.
In end went local with Osprey 565HT with 140 4/s. Great boat, 23 deg deadrise, very fine entry, stable, top workmanship, probably the deepest V of any pontoon boat. Built like a brick s***house. For its size and pontoon config it rides well in chop, really eats it. It needs the hp,happy with the 140, but a 150 would push it to perform at level that steps suggests.
cant say enough about the factory elert alloy trailers, easy launch and retrieval system. drive on/off self latching system.
There may be tradeoffs with other boats, may not have hte internal beam of senator. But has a 100mm lip that enables access all around the boat which is handy.
worth a consideration.
|
Posted By: :Hunter:
Date Posted: 10 Jan 2018 at 10:36pm
Kandrew wrote:
Where does the 115 maximum hp for the 575 come from, my mates got a 150 Yamaha on his and it needs every bit of it in a big sea |
I think ure probably thinking of the old 5.8 which are rated to 150hp. 575 is rated by Surtees for max hp of 115. I have one with the 115 and it is a good setup with plenty of power, definitely doesn't need a 150.
|
Posted By: Dream
Date Posted: 10 Jan 2018 at 11:12pm
offcut1 wrote:
Thanks for the input guys. Steps, the 1600kg is an extreme number. Obviously fully loaded you don't have to carry the keel ballast so max of 1400kg is probably more reasonable. It looks like the 115 would be the way to go for a 575.
Does anyone know much about the 550 Workmate Hardtop? Is it a big step down from the 575 in terms of ride and deck space? 25cm doesn't seem like much but it depends where it is lost from.
The one boat off my list I haven't had a look at yet is the Frewza F18 hardtop. Considering the Frewza fan forum on here is 160 pages long I thought I'd be overcome by Frewza owners. Anyone had much to do with them? They look like a hard riding boat to me but they seem to have a lot of fans. |
Speak to NZfisher he previously own a F18 Hardtop.
We own one as well, love it but can't compare since I've never been in a Surtees or Extreme etc.
If you do get one make sure to go for 130-140hp.
|
Posted By: Steps
Date Posted: 11 Jan 2018 at 10:43am
Where does the 115 maximum hp for the 575 come from, my mates got a 150 Yamaha on his and it needs every bit of it in a big sea
In my case explained in the post, Quick summary.. based on advertised and actual hp at the prop on most modern engines being different also on the boat models max rated hp.. taking into consideration the above. And on a revised estimate of boat weight being closer to 1200 kg rather than 1600. FULLY LOADED Get up over 1350 and the actual well powered 140Hp At the prop becomes 150hp as you state.
As I stated above, get to most 5.5m boats be glass or alloy fully loaded , not carrying tanks is ball park 1100/ 1250 kg 130/ 140 hp actual hp at the prop is very nicely powered for good chop performance and good 3800/ 4000 rpm cruise speeds . most boats between 5.6 to 6m get up into the 1700 with well powered 6m 200hp is well powered , 150, min thu more likely under powered.
With plaining hulls ..on the plain, its about the weight rather than the size.. thu with trailer boats being the normal over few decades ago the limit of beam size to water length is very different which changes constants dramatically.
|
|