Aitutaki - I went out with 3 charters - Black Pearl, Aitutaki Fishing Charters, and Wet'n Wild. I think they were all good - but I would prefer Wet'n Wild, which is owned by a young bloke down the far end of the airport runway - where the Lagoon resort is. We went on a day trip on the lagoon, not really fishing, mostly snorkelling (good), exploring a small island, barbecue on the beach sort of thing. He took us briefly outside the reef, where I lost the "stick bait" lure. He said he would do fishing trips around the island. His boat was a centre console full walk-around, which for popper fishing is great, as can move about, and two people can cast poppers out of each others way. The other two ran conventional cabin boats, and not ideal for more than one person casting; so I casted from up on the bow, which was hard. I think his rate was less than the other two, due probably to running a smaller cheaper boat.
Fishing we did mainly by trolling outside the reef - not very successful, few Wahoo, Mahimahi and Yellow-fin tuna caught. As with everywhere I think, sometimes they are there and keen, sometimes they aren't.
We popper fished for about an hour and a half one day - enough for me, as it was exhausting. The second fishing bloke caught a nice GT, I didnt but had a biggie on.
One thought - if going out with others, they might want to do different kinds of fishing, trolling, bottom fishing, or poppering. I think poppering is really only on if you have no more than two fishers; as thats about the max can cast without getting tangled. Two on a charter boat is rather expensive.