The Marine Reserve Machine – Unstoppable?

Marine reserves – the epitome of New Zealand’s pristine ocean environment; large tracts of ocean which are preserved for all to cherish and enjoy?  Progressively more and more proposals are being placed right around the country with many laying claim to some massive areas, seemingly more than is required.  Why is this?  Well the Department of Conservation (DOC) has set a self-proclaimed goal of 10% for our entire coastline to be enshrined into marine reserve status by the year 2010.  If they are going to come anywhere near this goal then a lot of extra large reserves have got to be pumped through the system and fast.  This must happen via a democratic process complete with consultation, notification, research and submission periods.  In achieving this edict DOC has come to rely heavily upon its partner, The Forest and Bird Protection Society F & B.  Together they make quite a formidable team and, so far, appear capable of anything they choose to do.  Consider a few well documented facts which have occurred during various recent marine reserve proposals.

 

Two South Island reserves, entering their last days of submission periods, were failing to achieve the necessary numbers for approval.  Without notification the period was inexplicably extended for another fortnight.  During this time the submissions poured in from F&B members, most living many hundreds of kilometres from the proposed sites.  Amazingly enough the proposals passed with flying colours!  Conversely, in another recent MR preliminary submission period (Volkner Rocks near White Island in the BOP) the approval rate was running at about 90%.  A few fishermen and spearos suddenly got their act together and the rate dropped to under 70% within a few days.  More declining submissions continued to arrive on DOC’s doorstep when an even more amazing thing happened – they were all shredded.  That’s right, shredded! As a direct consequence of this act, that reserve proposal is now entering its final submission phase.  In other events steering committees have been heavily stacked in their representation.  The percentage of Greens, F & B, DOC and passive members far outstripping a more proportional level representing all the users of any specified area.  Not surprisingly subsequent MR proposals have a decided slant.  Committee chairpersons have been outspoken in their approval of MR’s via the media.  While they obviously have their own personal opinions and should be able to voice them, this is not what their elected position should promote.  The emotive use of school children and even the recent death of one of our most celebrated statesman, Sir Peter Blake, are other very astute ploys in establishing MR’s.   There are other “anomalies” which could be mentioned but by now I think you’ll be getting the idea on the movement of this “democratic” process.

 

So when to from here?  A distinct “line in the sand” is approaching rapidly with the proposal of a MR at the Volkner Rocks.  This area is well offshore (nearly 30 nautical miles) and is protected accordingly by Mother Nature.  It has exceptional fish stocks which, aside from perhaps hapuka, are as prolific today as they were ten years ago.  The area is visited by relatively few and, due to its proximity, will continue in this vein (the exact opposite to the popular land based Leigh MR which is so close to a large population with excellent access).  Recreational anglers have fished the area over the years, mainly for pelagics during the summer months.  These distant rocks harbour a tremendous fishery, one which is heralded as world class.  The local charterboat fleets (Whakatane & Tauranga) recognised its uniqueness many years ago and established a voluntary code of practice in 1995.  This proactive pact guaranteed the sustainability of the localised yellowtail kingfish population by placing stringent limits on its passengers.  The best news is it’s worked, with a world-class fishery firmly intact.  The past users have been good guardians, ever so protective of this precious resource with results speaking for themselves.

 

Now, starting June 29th, the final submission period for this area has been implemented.  This proposal, and how it fares, will set precedents for many proposals (many already on the books) in the near future.  While the distant Volkner Rocks may seem far away to you now, the outcome of this MR proposal could have direct consequences for your local patch in the very near future.  You might like to have some thought about this and how it will pertain to you and your activities.  DOC plays the “numbers game” which counts each submission as one.  A submission from an organization or petition representing hundreds also counts as one! So, if you want your voice counted, you must respond as an individual, not letting your club act for you this time.  All it will take (if it’s not shredded) is a few sentences and a 40c stamp.  This isn’t much to ask for the determination of your future, what you do and where you can do it.

 

It would appear most everyone approves of Marine Reserves in principle.  They are, in the right context, a valuable commodity.  The numerous and huge reserves on the horizon are disturbing, especially for responsible divers and fishers who are overtly interested in sustainable stocks.  A vote against the proposed Volkner Rocks Marine Reserve is not a vote against marine reserves, only the enormity and process by which it proceeded.  If you are interested in voicing your opinion please respond to the address below.

 

Remember, once in place, marine reserves are forever.

 

                                      DOC

                             Bay of Plenty Conservancy

                             P O Box 1146

                             ROTORUA         

 

Rate this

Comments

Post a Comment

Required Field

Fishing bite times for Auckland, New Zealand on Wednesday 18 November 2026 Fishing bite times for Auckland, New Zealand on Wednesday 18 November 2026

Wednesday 18 November

Major Bites

Good Major bite time for Auckland on Wednesday 18 November between 18:57 - 20:57 -
Fair Major bite time for Auckland on Wednesday 18 November between 06:36 - 08:36 -

Minor Bites

Poor Minor bite time for Auckland on Wednesday 18 November between 10:14 - 13:14 -
Poor Major bite time for Auckland on Wednesday 18 November between 23:05 - 02:05 -

Thursday 19 November

Major Bites

Good Major bite time for Auckland on Thursday 19 November between 19:40 - 21:40 -
Fair Major bite time for Auckland on Thursday 19 November between 07:18 - 09:18 -

Minor Bites

Poor Minor bite time for Auckland on Thursday 19 November between 11:16 - 14:16 -
Poor Major bite time for Auckland on Thursday 19 November between 23:30 - 02:30 -

More bite times

Fishing Reports Visit Reports

Saltwater Fishing Reports
Raglan Fishing Report - 12/11/26

Big spring snapper. With the more settled weather over the last couple of weeks there’s... Read More >

12 Nov 2026
Saltwater Fishing Reports
Mercury Bay Fishing Report - 12/11/26

Snapper hit and miss. Most reports have been telling us it’s becoming more difficult to... Read More >

12 Nov 2026
Saltwater Fishing Reports
Northland Fishing Report - 12/11/26

The switch has been flicked on! Call it what you want, El Niño, global warming,... Read More >

12 Nov 2026
Saltwater Fishing Reports
Tauranga Fishing Report - 12/11/26

Snapper and kahawai in close. Again, we start on a positive note, with some nice... Read More >

12 Nov 2026