Print Page | Close Window

Biting but not hooking

Printed From: The Fishing Website
Category: Saltwater Fishing
Forum Name: Newbies Corner
Forum Description: If you're new to fishing this is the place to ask any questions about getting started ...
URL: https://www.fishing.net.nz/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=133458
Printed Date: 23 Nov 2026 at 5:30am


Topic: Biting but not hooking
Posted By: Glenn120903
Subject: Biting but not hooking
Date Posted: 02 May 2020 at 5:28pm
Hi all - new to everything fishing but started kayak fishing very recently and had a few Snapper out in first few outings but couple of things make me think I’m doing something wrong - first I don’t seem to get bites when reeling the lure in (as I thought was the right technique) but when I’m sitting in one spot I can be getting constant bites... which leads me into the second issue - I get many bites but rarely hook anything - often at the expense of my softbait... that said I have had three snapper in as many trips out but shouldn’t my ratio be better!? I’m fishing in 3m depth using 3/8jighead with Gulp 5inch. Thanks.



Replies:
Posted By: MB
Date Posted: 02 May 2020 at 5:40pm
I suspect leatherjackets or sub-legal snapper will be responsible. Three snapper in three trips is great for a beginner with sofites. Patience, grasshopper!  


Posted By: Glenn120903
Date Posted: 02 May 2020 at 6:36pm
Yes master 👏. 😀 thanks.

But should I continue leaving the soft bait in one spot rather than casting and luring?


Posted By: MB
Date Posted: 02 May 2020 at 6:55pm
If you are literally leaving it still on the sea bed, I would suggest that leatherjackets or other undesirables are doing the biting. Keep it moving, but make sure it sinks to the bottom every now and then.


Posted By: smudge
Date Posted: 02 May 2020 at 7:07pm
Originally posted by Glenn120903 Glenn120903 wrote:

Yes master 👏. 😀 thanks.

But should I continue leaving the soft bait in one spot rather than casting and luring?

I presume you're drifting if fishing in a kayak. Cast slightly ahead so you drift toward where you cast. In only 3m you don't want to be heaving that thing up off the bottom just a gentle lift and drop. then repeat. A softbait with a lot of action (wiggly bits) is what i'be using. 

What gear are you using & where are you fishing? Try to mix things up a little, you will get the same results if you do the same thing. That said I agree with the Boosh, 3 snapper isn't too bad for your first 3 trips out!


-------------
Best gurnard fisherman in my street


Posted By: PJay
Date Posted: 02 May 2020 at 9:44pm
IMHO, kayaks and softbaiting were made for each other.

Here are the very basics. You will elaborate and develop your own techniques as time goes on.

First essential (as mentioned above): drift.

Secondly, cast in the direction you're drifting.

Thirdly, once you think the SB is on the bottom (typically a 5" jerkshad on 3/8 oz jighead will sink at 60cm a second), then start winding it back to you - reel in gear, or bail arm closed if spinning reel: jerk jerk jerk, wind slack out of line whilst lowering rod tip, jerk jerk jerk etc, repeat until you have the SB back, cast again.

Do not strike when you feel a bite; just lift the rod tip firmly (reel in gear/bail arm over of course).

Mantra for finding fish: "current and structure".

You can catch fish by just dragging the SB along the bottom as you drift, but most of us find fishing more actively, as above, works better.

Some years ago, I wrote up a list of "PJ's Top 10 Softbaiting Tips" for an address at the NZ Softbait Champs that Joe Dennehy used to run. I'll see if I can find it and post if you're interested. (NB plenty of people disagree with some of my points, one of which IIRC was "develop your own style".)


-------------
PJ


Posted By: Glenn120903
Date Posted: 02 May 2020 at 9:51pm
Fishing manly bay off Whangaparaoa about 100 to 200 metre or so from the rocks and yes good point I am drifting - will take your advice on the approach.

Just wasn’t sure if I was not striking quickly enough or something but probably smaller snapper or something as you say.

Gear just a Shakespeare 7ft Rod, reel softbait combo - inexpensive starter kit

Cheers guys.


Posted By: smudge
Date Posted: 02 May 2020 at 10:05pm
Originally posted by Glenn120903 Glenn120903 wrote:

Fishing manly bay off Whangaparaoa about 100 to 200 metre or so from the rocks and yes good point I am drifting - will take your advice on the approach.

Just wasn’t sure if I was not striking quickly enough or something but probably smaller snapper or something as you say.

Gear just a Shakespeare 7ft Rod, reel softbait combo - inexpensive starter kit

Cheers guys.

PJay is an expert softbaiter/kayaker - take his advice! Nothing wrong with that gear. What weight braid and leader are you using?


-------------
Best gurnard fisherman in my street


Posted By: Nek minnit
Date Posted: 02 May 2020 at 10:33pm
Use the lightest jig head possible in 3m it should be tiny..... cast and wind slowly. But if there are no fish in the area there's no fish. Look for birds working.


Posted By: Glenn120903
Date Posted: 02 May 2020 at 11:41pm
Thanks Pjay there is some stuff there I will start to put into practice - tomorrow hopefully. would love to get the tips you mentioned, if
you don’t mind. up to now I’m just kind of self learning (fortunately had Smudge’s video on filleting as would have made a mess of that 😀) so any help I can get will only improve things. BTW when you mention ‘current and structure’ ... can you elaborate on that?

Thanks again for your help!

Glenn


Posted By: Glenn120903
Date Posted: 02 May 2020 at 11:48pm
Actually the reel came with mono line spooled on... having read some earlier posts regards the difference I imagine this is the weakest part of my set up... probably worth getting braid loaded on with a leader? I mean it’s doing a job, I’m catching but probably losing feel of what’s happening at the SB perhaps.

What sort of weight should I be looking at?


Posted By: Fish Addict
Date Posted: 03 May 2020 at 12:19am
Re-spool with braid …….. tick


Posted By: smudge
Date Posted: 03 May 2020 at 8:48am
Nek Minnit & Fish Addict both give good advice. If you're only ever fishing in 3m you may get by with mono but braid is many times better because it has less mass and doesn't stretch. It gets to the bottom easier and you will feel the takes and also when it hits the bottom. Any deeper and you will certainly need braid, Even in 3m if you cast out 10m you will get benefits from using braid.

A quality braid such as Daiwa J Braid is the go. It 's probably best if you take your reel to a tackle shop and ask them to respool it but that will depend on this covid drama as to when you can do that. You will need to learn a good knot to join braid to mono. You don't want a swivel to join the two. The leader should be mono, I use about 2m of 20lb mono for the leader so it's easy to get a wrap around the mono from a boat. I imagine a kayak would be the same. 

I like to use Mustad Fastach clips so that I don't need to retie hooks in the leader,each time I change a lure or softbait, otherwise the leader gets shorter and shorter. 

Tidal current and wind will determine which way you r kayak will drift. Cast so you will drift toward where your lure lands. so that eventually you will end up directly over the lure.

There are a few basics for you but the others will know much more about it because I'm not a kayak fisherman.



-------------
Best gurnard fisherman in my street


Posted By: kaveman
Date Posted: 03 May 2020 at 8:49am
If you have been using mono, that will be half your problem. Respool with 10-12lb braid( dont go too heavy) and get some good 16-20lb flurocarbon leader. (use 2m leader normally and as it gets shorter from tieing knot to jighead(lefties loop)
if you are fishing in very shallow water,(2-4m) try a 1/16th oz jighead, once you go a bit deaper, go up the 3/8oz
Always drift, never anchor. cast forward of the drift. Keep the softbait moving, jerkshads need more action than either a paddletail or curlytails.
If you are losing baits all the time, try using a more durable softbait, gulp are very good baits but dont last long when leather jackets eat them.
I would tend to drift and fish the outside of the weed line along the coast and fish that depth personally, check google maps of the area you fish, you will see the colour change close to the shoreline( normally blue and colour changes to white when over sand) , it is normally more like 7-12m depth that the rocky and kelp becomes sand, if you can drift this edge of kelp and sand, you will get better results. Fish hide in the kelp and come out too feed.
ps, make sure hook is sharp
Good luck


-------------
www.kavemantackle.co.nz


Posted By: smudge
Date Posted: 03 May 2020 at 9:11am
This is the knot I use to join mono to braid. It's called the FG knot 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JsupznHQ4tw" rel="nofollow - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JsupznHQ4tw

I don't hold the braid in my mouth, instead I tie a little loop in the end of the braid and slip that loop over the reel handle. Just put a little tension on the braid by winding the reel. You only need enough tension to keep the braid straight. You then put the rod in the rod holder and it keeps everything steady. Something to practice when the weather is bad.



-------------
Best gurnard fisherman in my street


Posted By: Steps
Date Posted: 03 May 2020 at 9:19am
Our softbaiting , well we hedge our bets..run both.
We boat drift, 2 to 30m,  never anchor unless off the west coast.
Sort of do what the jetski guys and kakakers don , except in the boat.

Choose spot, cruise in well above the drift line...
Flick the sb forward, let sink, and keep 'in touch' with the lure.. ie can always feel it there on the rod.. and that is where braid comes in.
Sort of flick it bck keeping in mind the boat is also heading towards the sb as well....then we go over it, and lot smaller flicks as we move away from the sb out the back...
 Which is more like strayling on the drift.

We send out the SB while dragging straylines out the back.
Often the strayline has a fish, we just drop the sb in the holder...and as all our reels are baitrunners, this is set just 'firm' if it gets hit...and often does get hit just dragging like a strayline.

The biggest thing I found to get right with a sb, is feel get hit and sort of pull back, feel the hook sink in, rather than a jerk.
Sort of like stray line with re curves, let the fish run, then slowly pull the fish up and have the hook roll and turn in... then load it to make sure the hook is in.

Either way have to have braid to fell exactly what is happening down there... and remove huge amounts of stretch in a mono line, so have direct contact with hook and fish.

I must admit, thu have 2 weights.. 3/8oz and 5/8oz, and more often than not using the 5/8 even in shallow water.. to lazy or busy to change as already have feed in the bin. Which I believe hurts our strike rate there to some degree.



Posted By: Glenn120903
Date Posted: 03 May 2020 at 11:53am
Hi all - thanks a lot for all your help, more than I expected- loads there for me to absorb and practice when the weather calms down a bit up here. Will definitely get the braid on spool ASAP- that seems a no brainer.
Thanks again!


Posted By: PJay
Date Posted: 03 May 2020 at 10:14pm
Well, this I see was written nearly 10 years ago....still all applies. Ask questions as much as you like; in "NZ Fishing News" articles, and indeed posts years back on this forum, I've explained the reasoning and experience behind every one of these tips.

(NB as others have mentioned, braid line is a must-have, for all the reasons stated. It's so routine I didn't put it in the "Top 10 Tips".)

PJ’S TOP 10 TIPS FOR SOFTBAITING

1.      Everyone has their own style. Put in the time, and you’ll develop yours. Just put in the time.

2.     Softbait colours don’t matter a lot; contrasting colours within SBs may help.

3.     These are lures; scent is secondary to movement. If using jerkshads, work them a lot.

4.     Use rods that are fairly stiff in the tips. Rod tips that fold away mean you must strike at hits (and so pull the bait away exactly at hook-up time), and also inhibit the lift your rod should have. I may as well have used handlines as some of the “specialist SB rods” I’ve used.

5.     Small hooks are much better than big hooks. I’ve caught 3 snapper over 1 metre on Nitro/Owner 1/0s.

6.     Don’t get carried away with multiple jighead weights. I use 1/2oz in all water depths 1m to 50m and more.

7.     Use low profile baitcaster reels. They have many advantages over spinning reels and other overheads, and with moderate practice no loss of casting distance. [Note many of the experts disagree with this, big-time. I stand by the statement.]

8.     Work the SB against current/tide flow. Depending on wind direction, this means you may be casting in any direction compared with your direction of drift.   It’s not really as simple as “cast in the direction you’re drifting” or “let the bait trail behind as you’re drifting”.

9.     Make your mantra “current and structure”. Think about where fish position themselves compared with structure. Use trout stream fishing as your model.

10.     Think kelp. The best snapper and kingfish tend to hang out in and around Ecklonia. Then think about how to winkle the fish out from there, both to bite your bait and also while you’re playing them.


-------------
PJ


Posted By: smudge
Date Posted: 03 May 2020 at 11:26pm
8.     Work the SB against current/tide flow. Depending on wind direction, this means you may be casting in any direction compared with your direction of drift.   It’s not really as simple as “cast in the direction you’re drifting” or “let the bait trail behind as you’re drifting”.

ThaT's interesting PJay


-------------
Best gurnard fisherman in my street


Posted By: PJay
Date Posted: 04 May 2020 at 8:27am
Yes, the prey fish generally face into current, looking for scraps and morsels coming their way (like trout in a stream), and the predator fish (that we want) tend to come up from behind them - also, from behind SBs to nab them, therefore.

You see the evidence, very often, with tail-nipped softbaits.

-------------
PJ


Posted By: Glenn120903
Date Posted: 04 May 2020 at 9:28am
Thanks Pjay for the advice.... and Braid already ordered.

Thanks all.


Posted By: coroben
Date Posted: 04 May 2020 at 9:36am
3 snapper over 1m? wow


Posted By: PJay
Date Posted: 04 May 2020 at 10:16am
Yup - I've weighed in somewhere around 10 softbait-caught snapper over 22lb, just in competitions...

2 of the 3 plus-1m ones were off the kayak; I have measures marked on the sides of my kayaks, the base mark being at my foot, then 50, 60, 70, 80, 90 and 100cm, the last one being up by my hip.

Here's a trip report from a Northland Kayak Fishing Club champs day now nine years ago, to whet your appetite: http://www.fishing.net.nz/asp_forums/kayak-softbait-fishing-bland-bay-29-may-2011_topic66529.html" rel="nofollow - http://www.fishing.net.nz/asp_forums/kayak-softbait-fishing-bland-bay-29-may-2011_topic66529.html

-------------
PJ


Posted By: laidbackdood
Date Posted: 04 May 2020 at 8:04pm
Use a smaller soft bait..try a 4 inch one....5 inch and 7 inch are quite big ...use a newk chicken and nitro 3/0 hook and a genie clip....so its easy to change over.....you will get a lot more hook ups on a 3/0 nitro compared to a 5/0....check your point regular(important/this might be why you are not hooking up.as well as the other reasons people have mentioned).....you need a sharp point for soft baiting....u will quite often get nailed as the bait nears underneath your boat/yak.....so cast ahead of the drift ...so it drifts towards you and along side your yak....twitches.....Thats my take anyway.....i got a 16 pound snapper like that.

-------------
Once the idiots turn up..Im outta here...No time for Drama Queens.



Print Page | Close Window