In my opinion, both Gulp and Zman have their pros and cons and the effectiveness of each one depends on various factors such as fishing techniques, species being targeted, water conditions and personal preferences.

Gulp is a versatile bait that can be fished both as a static lure or a worked lure. It is known for its lifelike appearance and taste which attracts fish and keeps them biting even after the initial strike.

However, it is fragile and may not hold up well against sharp-toothed fish. On the other hand, Zman is a durable plastic lure that excels as a traditional soft-plastic lure.

Its buoyancy and flexibility make it an attractive choice for anglers. However, it is less effective as a taste lure and may require frequent re-application of flavour to be effective. In conclusion, it is recommended to have a variety of lures in your tackle box and use them based on the specific fishing conditions and species being targeted. Both Gulp and Zman have their place in fishing and can be effective in different situations.